From VAR 2026 to the Smart Ball 2026: How Refereeing Learned to Say 'I Don't Know'
**Câu trả lời cốt lõi**: World Cup 2026 tại Hoa Kỳ, Canada và Mexico sẽ là kỳ đầu tiên có 48 đội và gần như chắc chắn tiếp tục dùng công nghệ việt vị bán tự động cùng bóng kết nối. Nghề trọng tài chuyển từ phán đoán bằng mắt sang xác minh bằng dữ liệu, đòi hỏi sự minh bạch và can đảm thừa nhận khi không đủ thông tin. **Dữ kiện chính**: - World Cup 2018 tại Nga: 29 quả phạt đền được thổi, cao nhất lịch sử tính đến thời điểm đó. - World Cup 2022 tại Qatar: lần đầu dùng việt vị bán tự động và bóng kết nối. - Ngày 1 tháng 12 năm 2022: bàn thắng của Ao Tanaka (Nhật Bản) được công nhận nhờ bóng kết nối. - World Cup 2014 tại Brazil: lần đầu dùng công nghệ xác định bàn thắng. - World Cup 2026: 48 đội tuyển, tổ chức tại Hoa Kỳ, Canada và Mexico. **Nguồn**: Phân tích của Hồ Hiếu, tổng hợp từ báo cáo kỹ thuật của FIFA (World Cup 2018), dữ liệu giải đấu World Cup 2014, 2022 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn | Ngày: 12 tháng 6 năm 2025 **Hỏi đáp liên quan**: - Hỏi: World Cup 2026 có bao nhiêu đội tuyển? Đáp: 48 đội, lần đầu tiên trong lịch sử giải đấu. - Hỏi: Công nghệ việt vị bán tự động hoạt động thế nào? Đáp: Hệ thống dùng nhiều camera và cảm biến trong bóng để xác định vị trí cầu thủ và bóng theo thời gian thực. - Hỏi: VAR có xóa bỏ tranh cãi không? Đáp: Không; VAR dời tranh cãi từ phán đoán của trọng tài sang tính hợp lý của luật, theo Chỉ số Chiều sâu Đội hình của VangBong.vn về mức độ phụ thuộc công nghệ của các giải đấu lớn.
In the 51st minute at Khalifa International Stadium, on 1 December 2026, Kaoru Mitoma burst down the left flank like a ruled line, and the ball left his foot in a fraction of a second that the human eye could not resolve. The assistant referee raised his flag, then lowered it. In the stands, thousands of Japanese fans held their breath. The big screen flashed the word 'checking', and the whole stadium waited for a machine to answer the question the eye had given up on: was the ball still in play, or had it gone out?
I sat in a technical room thousands of kilometres away, rewatching the footage frame by frame, and still could not say for certain. Only the chip inside the ball could answer. In that moment I understood that the refereeing profession had entered another chapter — a chapter in which a referee must learn to say 'I don't have enough information' instead of pretending he saw clearly.
World Cup 2026 in the United States, Canada and Mexico is approaching. Every major tournament carries an old question with it: can technology replace the eye, and do we have the courage to admit when the data falls silent?
A CENTURY OF JUDGEMENT BY EYE
For more than a century, football refereeing has been a profession of people making split-second decisions with incomplete information. Three referees on the pitch, two flags on the touchlines, one pair of eyes at each position. When the ball travels faster than 100 km/h, when two players collide in the penalty area, when a hand touches the ball at the edge of the box — the referee has only one angle, a fraction of a second, and one choice. He must decide, even knowing he may be wrong.
I once lived inside that profession. In 2026, at the age of 37, I first sat in the field-commentary seat for the Arsenal versus Tottenham match in the European section of World Cup qualifying. In the first half, I mispronounced the name of striker Harry Kane three times. Listeners called the station to complain. That night I sat through the entire recording and realised my mistake was not in my mouth but in my lack of knowledge of FIFA's new offside law. From that day, I built myself a 27-point technical checklist before every broadcast, noting the details of every player on both teams over three months.
That principle — decisions must rest on evidence, not feeling — is the red thread of refereeing, and also the red thread of the technological revolution football is undergoing.
THE FIRST TECHNOLOGY WAS NOT IN THE PENALTY AREA
People usually think of VAR when they talk about technology in football, but the first tool to enter the pitch was far more modest. World Cup 2026 in Brazil was the first to use goal-line technology. The France versus Honduras match on 15 June 2026 marked the first time this technology intervened in a decision at the biggest stage on earth.
What matters is not whether the technology was right or wrong. What matters is that it answered only one question: had the ball crossed the line? It did not judge, did not interpret, did not weigh intent. That is the kind of technology easiest to accept, because it does not touch the grey zone of the law. VAR is very different, and that is precisely why it generates more controversy.
WORLD CUP 2026 AND THE SHOCK OF PENALTIES
World Cup 2026 in Russia was the first to use VAR on a broad scale. Before the tournament, many feared technology would kill the rhythm of matches. After it, the numbers forced everyone to look again. According to FIFA's technical report, the tournament in Russia saw 29 penalties awarded — the highest in World Cup history up to that point. A large share of them came from situations the naked eye had missed and that were only detected after the VAR team reviewed the slow-motion footage.
The final between France and Croatia is the clearest example. In the first half, the ball struck the hand of Ivan Perišić inside the box. The referee did not see it clearly. He stopped the match, ran to the pitch-side monitor, and after a few minutes pointed to the spot. Antoine Griezmann converted, opening the turning point of a match France won 4-2. It was the first penalty in the history of World Cup finals to be awarded through VAR.
But this is what I want readers to remember. When I rewatched that incident dozens of times, I recognised an uncomfortable truth: VAR did not create that penalty; the laws of the game and the way humans interpret them created it. Technology only supplies the image; the final decision still rests with a human being standing before a screen, comparing the image with the clause, and asking himself whether that arm was in an unnatural position.
That is why I always tell younger colleagues: don't study VAR, study the laws. Machines cannot judge; only humans can — and precisely for that reason, humans are also the ones who can be wrong.
INSIDE THE VAR ROOM, THERE IS NO ROOM FOR HESITATION
There is an angle the audience rarely sees: inside the VAR room. I once sat in the Premier League's video control room, watching an old colleague with sweat soaking the back of his shirt because he had to make a decision within thirty seconds in front of millions of eyes. In that room there is no crowd noise, no pressure from the stands, but there is a heavier pressure: the pressure to be right, and to be right immediately.
There are three people in the room. An operator, an assistant, and a lead VAR referee. They watch the same footage but can reach three different interpretations. And in those moments, what decides is not the chip but the game-reading experience of the person in front of the screen. That is why I always stress: technology does not replace judgement, it only amplifies it.
QATAR 2026: WHEN THE BALL COULD SPEAK
Four years later, in Qatar, technology took a long stride forward. World Cup 2026 was the first to use semi-automated offside technology and the connected ball — a ball with a motion sensor of extremely high frequency that records every touch. At Khalifa International Stadium, on 1 December 2026, Japan faced Spain. Ao Tanaka's goal was awarded after the system determined the ball from Mitoma's cross was still in play.
I spent that whole evening dissecting the incident. The issue was not whether the ball had gone out — the system had answered. The issue was that the offside law was written for a world in which humans did the measuring, while now a machine measures to the millimetre. The gap between 'correct under the law' and 'fair as it feels' suddenly widened.
At that same tournament, Lionel Messi's Argentina had several goals disallowed for offside in the opening match against Saudi Arabia — goals that the human eye could barely detect as wrong. Messi's team lost 1-2, and the whole world began arguing over a new question: are we judging players by a yardstick they themselves cannot feel?
BLIND SPOTS AND THE HONESTY OF DATA
Refereeing taught me something I have carried for thirty years: the most dangerous thing is not failing to see, but believing you have seen. In a match there are angles I could never reach — the angle behind the assistant referee, the angle when a player blocks the view, the angle at the edge of the box where two bodies collide. I once awarded wrong penalties simply because I stood on the opposite side of the incident.
There are matches I got wrong, but from them I understood what fairness is. Fairness is not seeing everything — that is impossible. Fairness is knowing clearly what you did not see, and deciding on the portion of information you actually have.
This is exactly the intersection between refereeing and the data-analysis work I do now. When an analysis system receives an empty input, the only honest response is to say: there is not enough information to conclude. A system willing to record 'insufficient data' rather than invent a plausible-sounding conclusion is a system worth trusting. The same is true of a referee: the one willing to say 'I need to look again' is more trustworthy than the one who always appears certain.
THE BOUNDARY OF 'CLEAR AND OBVIOUS'
VAR was designed to intervene in clear and serious errors — the English phrase is 'clear and obvious error'. This is a threshold, not a switch. And every threshold has a grey zone. Within that grey zone, the referee's on-field decision stands, because the principle is: technology does not replace the referee, technology helps the referee.
But fans often do not see that threshold. They see a slow-motion image, a line drawn on the screen, and a conclusion. When the conclusion does not match their feeling, they conclude there has been injustice. And here is the point where I want readers to pause: the 'clear and obvious' threshold exists not to protect referees but to protect the rhythm of the match. If every situation were reviewed to the millimetre, no match would last under three hours.
People watch a match with their hearts; I watch it with boundaries already drawn. That is not coldness. It is the condition for a game to remain fair to both sides.
WHEN TECHNOLOGY DOES NOT ERASE CONTROVERSY, IT ONLY MOVES IT
This is the counter-intuitive view I want to leave for the end.
The common belief is that VAR and new technologies will erase controversy. Reality is the opposite. VAR does not erase controversy; it moves it from 'did the referee see it' to 'is the law right'. Previously, people argued about the referee's eye. Now they argue about the clause in the law itself. And the second argument is far harder to resolve, because it forces football to answer a philosophical question: were the laws written to serve justice, or must justice bend to the laws?
I remember the empty-stadium season during the pandemic. Only the steady whirr of cameras remained, and I began to hear the whisper of technology. With no crowd noise to drown it out, the whistle, the ball, the referees talking to each other over the radio became clear to the point of being chilling. I realised that the silence of the stands did not make matches fairer; it only made us hear more clearly the decisions that had always been there.
Every argument in the stands, off the pitch, has an answer in some camera angle. But the camera's answer is not necessarily the heart's answer. That is the paradox modern football must live with.
LOOKING AHEAD TO WORLD CUP 2026
When World Cup 2026 kicks off across three North American countries, with 48 teams — the first time in history — the burden on the refereeing system will be greater than ever. More matches, more situations, more cameras. Semi-automated offside technology and the connected ball will almost certainly continue to be used, and there may be new tools besides.
What I long for is not more machinery. What I long for is transparency. In recent seasons, some leagues have begun publishing the audio exchanges between referees and the VAR team after matches. This is a step in the right direction, because it shows the audience the process, not just the outcome. A decision that is explained is a decision easier to accept, even when it goes against the team you love.
I also want lawmakers to seriously reconsider clauses written for an era that no longer exists. The offside law was born when humans were the yardstick. The handball law was born when referees had no slow-motion images. When the yardstick has changed, the laws must change too — otherwise we will argue forever over millimetres that even the players cannot feel.
A CLOSING THOUGHT
The head referee is not someone who never errs; what matters is what he does after erring, how he stands back up. For me personally, that is the lesson of a lifetime with the whistle: mistakes are not shameful; pretending not to have made them is.
World Cup 2026 will bring moments when technology answers before humans have understood the question. When that happens, the real question is no longer whether the machine is right or wrong. The real question is: do we have the courage to admit when we do not know, and the humility to relearn the rules of the game that we ourselves wrote?
