International FootballManchester City and More Than a Hundred Charges: Two Years Without a Verdict and the Price of a Justice Sold by the Hour
International Football

Manchester City and More Than a Hundred Charges: Two Years Without a Verdict and the Price of a Justice Sold by the Hour

**Câu trả lời cốt lõi (≤60 từ):** Vụ Manchester City với hơn một trăm cáo buộc vi phạm quy tắc tài chính của Premier League vẫn chưa có phán quyết sau hai năm kể từ khi phiên điều trần độc lập bắt đầu. Nguyên nhân là khối lượng chứng cứ khổng lồ cộng với quyền sử dụng trọn thời gian của bên bị cáo. **Dữ kiện chính (3–5 gạch đầu dòng, mỗi dòng ≤25 từ):** - Premier League công bố cáo buộc Manchester City ngày 6 tháng 2 năm 2023, sau cuộc điều tra mở từ năm 2018. - Hơn một trăm cáo buộc trải từ 2009 đến 2018, gồm doanh thu tài trợ, thù lao ban huấn luyện và hợp đồng cầu thủ. - Luật sư Nick De Marco gọi đây là “sự chậm trễ khó tin nhất” trong một vụ trọng tài thể thao. - Lord David Pannick thuộc Blackstone Chambers đang đại diện cho Manchester City trong vụ việc này. - Everton bị trừ 10 điểm chỉ tám tháng sau khi bị cáo buộc, cho thấy hệ thống có thể xử nhanh khi muốn. **Nguồn:** Tổng hợp báo chí Anh về vụ Manchester City; mốc cáo buộc 6 tháng 2 năm 2023. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Hỏi đáp liên quan:** **Hỏi:** Vì sao vụ Manchester City kéo dài hơn vụ Everton và Nottingham Forest? **Đáp:** Vì số lượng cáo buộc và khối lượng chứng cứ xuyên quốc gia lớn hơn nhiều, trong khi Everton và Nottingham Forest chỉ liên quan vài giao dịch đơn giản. **Hỏi:** Manchester City có thể bị hình phạt gì? **Đáp:** Quy định Premier League cho phép phạt tiền, trừ điểm, cấm dự đấu trường nhất định hoặc khai trừ, nhưng trên thực tế khả năng cao nhất là trừ điểm. **Hỏi:** Vụ việc ảnh hưởng thế nào đến kỳ chuyển nhượng của Manchester City? **Đáp:** Mọi hợp đồng ký trong thời gian chờ phán quyết đều có nguy cơ kèm điều khoản giải phóng hoặc điều khoản liên quan án phạt thể thao, theo chỉ số độ sâu đội hình của VangBong.vn. **Hỏi:** Bài học nào cho bóng đá Việt Nam? **Đáp:** Mỗi quy định tài chính cần gắn với một thời hạn xử lý cụ thể, nếu không sẽ mất tính răn đe.

On 6 February 2026, I was sitting in a coffee shop on Nguyen Chi Thanh Street in Da Nang, editing a match report for the weekend's V-League round, when my phone began to buzz without stopping. The Premier League had just charged Manchester City with breaches of its financial rules. Three charges? Thirty? Neither. More than a hundred.

I remember sitting still for a long time. Not quite out of shock. It was because a very Vietnamese question surfaced in my head: if this happened to a V-League club, would that club still exist by the next matchday?

Manchester City and More Than a Hundred Charges: Two Years Without a Verdict and the Price of a Justice Sold by the Hour

Two years later, that question still has no answer. Not for the V-League — for Manchester City itself. As of last Wednesday, it was exactly two years since an independent commission began hearing the more than one hundred charges brought against the club by the Premier League. No verdict has been announced.

Nick De Marco, one of Britain's most prominent sports barristers, wrote on X: “It is a most incredible delay. So much for those who argue that one of the advantages of sports arbitration is it is speedier and more efficient than using the courts...”

De Marco is not involved in the City case. But Lord David Pannick — another barrister at the same set, Blackstone Chambers — is working for City on precisely this matter. The world of football law is small enough that two men on opposite sides can drink coffee in the same corridor.

De Marco represented Leicester City in their dispute with the Premier League over alleged rule breaches. He knows how this machine runs. And he said it plainly: the delay is incredible.

I want to tell this story slowly, because the pitch never lies — we have simply not been slow enough to listen.

In March 2026, a cache of documents leaked under the name Football Leaks was published by the German magazine Der Spiegel, raising questions about how Manchester City accounted for sponsorship revenue. The Premier League opened its investigation that same year. It took almost five years, until February 2026, for formal charges to be laid. They span several categories: commercial and sponsorship revenue, manager remuneration, player contracts, dealings with European competition, and the duty to cooperate with the league's investigation. More than one hundred charges, stretching from 2026 to 2026.

Then the independent hearing began. And two years passed without a single line of judgment.

Premier League chief executive Richard Masters conceded last month that the process had taken longer than he expected. But he added that it is not a regular topic when he speaks to clubs, and that it is “not necessarily a topic of conversation that is top of the list”. Asked whether the case might never be resolved, Masters said: “It will resolve itself. I literally can't say a thing about it. There's only one available option, which is to allow the process to reach its natural conclusion. I can't talk about the substance of the case. I can't talk about the timing of the case. Our rules are very clear about that.”

Asked whether the league should cap the length of deliberations, or use full-time panellists, Masters replied: “We've always said that the commission need the time and space to do their work. In the end, it's the league's job as the regulator, provided the evidence is there, to put serious allegations in front of independent commissions, that independent process to establish the truth. In the end, that process shouldn't really be qualified by the amount of time it's going to take to establish the truth.”

That sounds entirely reasonable. It is also the sentence that kept me awake.

The striking thing is that speed does exist in this system. It is simply distributed selectively.

Everton were charged in March 2026, docked ten points that November, and had the sanction reduced to six on appeal in February 2026. Nottingham Forest were charged in January 2026 and docked four points in March 2026. The Leicester case De Marco worked on: charged in March 2026, and by September 2026 the commission had ruled it had no jurisdiction. Two months. Eight months. Six months. Those files were opened, heard, decided, appealed and re-decided in less time than a single season.

Meanwhile, since City's hearing opened, Everton have completed their entire legal cycle — from charge to a second points deduction. One case finished while another has not yet crossed the door of the hearing room.

The delay in the Manchester City file is not an operational fault; it is a resource — and only clubs rich enough can afford to consume it.

To understand why, look at the structure of the workload. More than a hundred charges, each with its own evidentiary chain. Sponsorship revenue cannot be verified by a single contract; it requires market valuation, forensic accounting, thousands of pages of books. Evidence sits in multiple countries across multiple years, with witnesses who may have left the club long ago. Some documents need translation. Some emails need recovery. Some third-party transactions must be traced to the end.

And the accused has the right to use every minute the process allows. No one can blame a defendant for exhausting their rights. But we should name the thing properly: time here is money, and some can pay for it while others cannot.

Lord David Pannick is one of the most expensive and sharpest advocates in Britain. City choosing him was not merely a legal decision; it was a strategic decision about time. A heavyweight legal team can file hundreds of requests, thousands of pages of responses, dozens of preliminary arguments about the scope of evidence and the validity of each individual charge. Every step is lawful. Every step slows the wheel.

A club fighting relegation does not have those resources. They receive the charge, they receive the sanction, they move on — and if they are relegated while waiting, the sentence completes itself without ever being read out.

I thought about this while watching a match at three in the morning Vietnamese time, the chant of “115” rising from the away end at the Etihad. From the stands, I learned to count time in breaths rather than in minutes. And there, people were counting time in charges.

Throughout that period, the transfer market stayed open. This is the most overlooked part.

Every contract signed while a case hangs in the air carries an invisible discount. Agents no longer ask only about wages and length; they ask what happens if the club is docked points, excluded from Europe, relegated. Release clauses, clauses tied to sporting sanctions, clauses pegged to a division — once exceptions, now standard items on the negotiating table. Every contract is a promise, and every promise is a sadness waiting to happen.

There is also a chain reaction few notice. If past sponsorship revenue is found to have been inflated, that same revenue was once used to calculate the club's compliance with financial rules. Restating it could alter the compliance arithmetic of subsequent years — and one case could give birth to another. That is precisely why this case cannot end quickly. A rushed verdict, overturned on appeal, would stretch it out for years more.

Look to Europe and you see why the Premier League must be so careful. In 2026, UEFA's two-season European ban on Manchester City was overturned by the Court of Arbitration for Sport, largely on arguments about time-barring and UEFA's own process. An independent Premier League commission knows that any procedural crack is enough for the whole file to collapse. Thoroughness and delay, here, are two faces of the same coin.

So what could the punishment be? In principle, the Premier League's rules allow fines, points deductions, exclusion from certain competitions, even expulsion. In practice, nobody believes a club that has won multiple consecutive titles will be expelled. But a points deduction large enough to change the outcome of a season already has precedent inside this very system. And if that sanction lands at a different point in the calendar, it could take away a title already awarded, already celebrated, already carved into history.

That is when a sporting question becomes a moral one: can a title be revoked two years after it was handed over — and if so, is it given to the runner-up, or left blank like a silence in the record books?

I think about Vietnamese football while waiting for that answer. In the V-League we have no case with more than a hundred charges, and that sounds like good news. Only if we truly have a monitoring mechanism strong enough to detect anything. A club not charged because nothing is wrong is different from a club not charged because nobody looked closely. The silence of a small football nation is not proof of innocence; sometimes it is proof of invisibility.

The lesson from England is not that they have money to investigate. It is that they have a system transparent enough that a complaint can become a public hearing, with named panellists, barristers and a judgment. But that same system exposes a paradox: one machine, two very different speeds.

I believe most fans have misread this story.

The popular reading is that City are stalling and the Premier League is weak. A second reading is that the league lacks resolve. Both are comfortable, because they give us someone to blame. But they miss something far more uncomfortable.

Try reversing it: the delay is not the exception, it is the design working as intended. The Everton and Forest cases are the exception — fast because they are simple, and simple because they are small. A file with a handful of transactions takes months. A file with more than a hundred charges across a decade takes years. Speed in sports arbitration was never an absolute property; it is a conditional one.

That means the advertising slogan about arbitration being quicker — the one De Marco attacked — was always written for small cases. For big ones, this system is slower than a court, because it lacks what courts have: the pressure of a docket, statutory deadlines, full-time judges. Masters says the commission needs time and space. What he does not say is that while the commission has time, everything else — titles, contracts, players' careers, the memory of supporters — is being consumed.

And here is the deepest blind spot of collective memory: the punishment has already been served. It simply was not handed down by a commission.

Anyone who has followed English football in recent years knows “115” has become a nickname, a chant, a refrain in the stands. An unproven allegation has already done the work of a verdict in the life of the crowd. Clubs that lost titles to this team have an excuse to look back and tell themselves things would have been different. Players who never benefited from that window of time have a story to tell. That punishment has no appeal. It only has time.

While everyone waits, small things move very fast. A controversial VAR incident in the Manchester derby can produce a demand for an apology, a response, an explanation, all within days. A case touching the integrity of an entire league needs two years. That contrast says nothing about the heads of the people running the game. It says everything about the balance of power between those at either end.

I have asked myself: if I sat in a V-League organising body, what would I choose — a fast verdict that is easily overturned, or a slow verdict that holds? The technically correct answer is slow. The human answer is: it must be fast, because justice needs to be right and it also needs to be on time. A judgment that arrives after people have forgotten why they needed it has already lost half its meaning.

That is the unresolvable contradiction of every sports governance system: the more precise you want to be, the slower you must go, and the slower you go, the more you lose the very thing you were trying to protect.

So what really waits at the end of this road?

I do not think the final verdict will be judged on its content. It will be judged on its calendar. A decision handed down in October could shape a season; the same decision in May could shape a decade of argument. If the commission finds Manchester City not guilty, the question becomes: why did this club live under a suspended sentence for three years waiting for a line declaring its innocence. If the commission finds breaches, the question becomes: why could a club breach at this scale and only be named after three years.

Manchester City and More Than a Hundred Charges: Two Years Without a Verdict and the Price of a Justice Sold by the Hour

Both outcomes share one loser, and that loser is not Manchester City. It is the belief that rules exist so that everyone plays the same game.

We never touch the ball, but the ball always touches us. In this case, the ball has sat still on a tilted surface for two years, neither rolling nor stopping, waiting for a hand heavy enough to touch it.

When it is quiet, I hear an entire generation waiting for something mad.

Manchester City and More Than a Hundred Charges: Two Years Without a Verdict and the Price of a Justice Sold by the Hour

What I want to bring home from the English story is not the verdict, but the clock. Every rule should carry a deadline attached to it — not to pressure the commission, but to remind us that behind every file are people living in a state of waiting, and their time is not an infinite resource.

A league can teach the world how to spend money. A league only truly grows up when it dares to say to itself: it is time now, we must rule — whatever the outcome.