International FootballEmpty Reports and the N/A: How Football's Data Industry Is Fooling Itself with Paperwork
International Football
Empty Reports and the N/A: How Football's Data Industry Is Fooling Itself with Paperwork
**Câu trả lời cốt lõi:** Báo cáo phân tích bóng đá hiện đại thường chứa nhiều ô ghi N/A vì mô hình được huấn luyện trên các giải lớn châu Âu, còn cỡ mẫu và định nghĩa dữ liệu tại các giải nhỏ không đủ để kết luận. **Dữ kiện chính:** - Tệp PDF 41 trang với 213 ô dữ liệu, trong đó 178 ô ghi N/A. | Nguồn: báo cáo phân tích nội bộ Stage-2, công bố ngày 13 tháng 8 năm 2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn - Việt Nam thắng Thái Lan 3-2 ở Rajamangala ngày 5 tháng 1 năm 2025, chung cuộc 5-3, vô địch ASEAN Cup. - Nguyễn Xuân Son ghi bàn ở cả hai lượt chung kết và gặp chấn thương nặng ở lượt về. - Jiangsu FC vô địch Chinese Super League năm 2020 và bị giải thể năm 2021. - Liverpool tuyển Ian Graham năm 2012; Brentford lên Ngoại hạng Anh năm 2021. **Nguồn:** Báo cáo phân tích nội bộ Stage-2, công bố ngày 13 tháng 8 năm 2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Hỏi đáp liên quan:** Q: Vì sao chỉ số xG không dùng được cho ASEAN Cup? A: Vì mô hình xG được huấn luyện trên dữ liệu các giải lớn châu Âu, nên ngưỡng và ngữ cảnh không khớp với nhịp độ và chất lượng đội hình khu vực. Q: Chỉ số PPDA nói lên điều gì? A: PPDA đo số đường chuyền đối thủ được phép trước mỗi hành động phòng ngự; chỉ số càng thấp nghĩa là pressing càng quyết liệt, theo Chỉ số Cường độ Pressing của VangBong.vn. Q: Vì sao cỡ mẫu bốn trận khiến báo cáo ghi N/A? A: Vì mọi chỉ số tính theo chín mươi phút trên cỡ mẫu đó đều là nhiễu và không đủ để đưa ra kết luận có thể kiểm chứng.
At two in the morning Beijing time, my phone buzzed. An analyst in Shanghai sent me a forty-one page PDF. His only message was: “Tell me where I should start reading.”
I opened it. The cover page had a logo, a competition name, a date, an author. Page two was a team-metrics table. Page three was an individual-metrics table. Page four was a heat map. Page five was a bar chart comparing two midfields. Everything in the correct format, the correct typeface, the correct colour palette that analytics departments use when they present to coaching staff.
And of the two hundred and thirteen data cells in the entire file, one hundred and seventy-eight contained three characters: N/A.
Insufficient information. Insufficient data. Cannot be determined.
I read all forty-one pages in twenty minutes. It is the most beautifully produced document about a football match I have ever held. And it told me nothing.
My job is to read documents like this and turn them into something a reader can use. I have done that for eleven years, in Vietnam and then in China, from an intern scrubbing academy data at midnight to someone with a seat in the press room at major tournaments. I have read thousands of reports. This one was the most honest and the most useless.
I once got hammered for a week for saying something against the grain. I will say it again: football is producing a new kind of paperwork. It has the shape of knowledge, the smell of expertise, the signature of a qualified person. But inside it is hollow. And the frightening part is that we keep paying for it to stay hollow.
Football was not always like this. In 2026 a company called Prozone began selling camera-based tracking to English clubs. Sam Allardyce brought it to Bolton around 2026 and turned a squad of veterans into a top-half Premier League side. People laughed at his long-ball football. Nobody laughed at his spreadsheet.
In 2026, in Oakland, Billy Beane used numbers to take a baseball team with a quarter of its rivals’ budget to one hundred and three wins. The book written about him became scripture for every sporting director on the planet.
In 2026 Liverpool hired a Cambridge-trained physicist named Ian Graham. He sat in a small room, did not speak to the press, and over eleven years helped build a team that won the European Cup and the English league. He left in 2026 to start his own firm. In Denmark, Midtjylland won the domestic title in 2026 on a model built more on data than on eyes. In London, Matthew Benham’s Brentford reached the Premier League in 2026 by a nearly identical route.
Then it became an industry. A Premier League club now employs between five and twenty analysts. Data vendors sell annual subscriptions. Technology firms sell monthly dashboards. Sports conferences sell seats. A whole ecosystem has grown around one question: how do we know in advance what will happen on the pitch?
I have two markets to look at that question through, and I am lucky because they sit at opposite ends of the same truth.
China is where I live. Guangzhou Evergrande won the AFC Champions League in 2026 and 2026. Money poured in, analytics departments multiplied, foreign experts were paid well, reports got thicker. Then the money stopped. Jiangsu FC won the Chinese Super League in 2026 and was dissolved in 2026. Guangzhou were relegated in 2026. The analytics departments dissolved alongside the contracts. The lesson is not that data is worthless. The lesson is that data is the first thing cut when nobody is paying for it.
Vietnam is where I was born. I grew up watching football through my father’s eyes, not a spreadsheet. Then Park Hang-seo arrived in 2026, and Vietnam won the 2026 AFF Cup and reached the 2026 Asian Cup quarter-finals. Then Philippe Troussier arrived with a thicker, more systematic European playbook. In March 2026 Vietnam lost 0-3 to Indonesia at home, and he was gone. In May 2026 Kim Sang-sik arrived, less doctrine, more pragmatism. On 5 January 2026 Vietnam beat Thailand 3-2 at Rajamangala, 5-3 on aggregate over two legs, to win the ASEAN Cup.
Read those three moments side by side and you see something no data table will print: in all three, the thing that decided it was not in any column.
So let me talk about the anatomy of an empty report.
I do not believe the simple explanation that vendors are just bad. If that were all, the problem would have been fixed long ago. What I believe is a chain of incentives that makes N/A multiply, and the chain starts with who pays.
A vendor sells coverage. Not truth — filled cells. A report with ninety per cent coverage at sixty per cent confidence looks full. A report with forty per cent coverage at ninety-five per cent confidence looks empty. Buyers compare page counts, not epistemics. So the market price rewards filling boxes rather than telling the truth. I once sat in a Beijing meeting where a vendor representative proudly announced, in English, that they had reduced their blank-cell rate below ten per cent. Nobody asked what the accuracy rate was.
The second incentive is that models get transplanted into foreign soil. Every beautiful metric you read was trained on the big European leagues. Expected goals, pressing intensity, duel-success thresholds — all calibrated on hundreds of thousands of shots and passes in England, Spain, Italy, Germany and France. Take those benchmarks to the ASEAN Cup and you are using a hand-span to measure a football.
Expected goals is worse. A shot from the edge of the box is worth three to five per cent in a European model — an average across thousands of players, hundreds of goalkeepers, thousands of situations. It does not know the keeper is short and slow off his line. It does not know the shooter has a sore ankle. It knows coordinates, distance, angle and the nearest defender. It is a brilliant camera for geometry and a poor judge of people.
The third incentive is role classification. A player who spends four matches as a second striker and six on the left wing gets split into two rows, each below the minimum-minutes threshold. Both rows read N/A. A man who played nine hundred minutes vanishes from the report. Nobody deleted him on purpose. The machine simply has no place for a human being who changes job mid-season.
The fourth is sample size. Four matches, three hundred and sixty minutes. Every per-ninety metric on that sample is noise. The honest answer is N/A. The dishonest answer is a table, with a footnote nobody reads, that travels into a meeting and becomes a decision about a person’s career.
The fifth is measurement itself. The big leagues have a standard event framework. Smaller leagues, including the V.League, have had event data supplied over the years by different providers with different definitions. Does a contested header count as a duel or an aerial? Does a slightly deflected pass count as a loss of possession? If two providers answer differently, you cannot compare across seasons. So the cell reads N/A.
The sixth is human, and it hurts the most. The analyst knows. He watched the match. He saw the left-back step up too early three times, and the third time the opponent scored. He knows. But there is no cell called “left-back stepped up too early”. So he types N/A and tells the sporting director over coffee. The knowledge exists. It just does not travel with the paper.
Which brings me to the match I use as a test for every report.
On 5 January 2026, Vietnam beat Thailand 3-2 in Bangkok, 5-3 on aggregate, to win the ASEAN Cup. I watched from Beijing, then re-watched the tape three times that week, and asked myself what a modern analytics department would produce from it. Possession. Shots. Passes. Duels. Twenty pages of clean data.
But there was one event no column could hold: Nguyen Xuan Son, who had scored in both legs, suffered a serious injury and had to leave the pitch. A team playing a final away from home, losing its main striker mid-match, still winning. In the standard file there is a cell called “response to adversity”. What does it say? Insufficient information. No model has been trained to quantify a team keeping its shape after losing its most important player. There are no coordinates for it.
That is what I mean by an empty report. The blanks are not scattered randomly. They cluster around exactly the places where matches are decided.
I am not anti-data. I once wrote that a sixteen-year-old midfielder in Barcelona’s academy played twice as many line-breaking passes as his team’s average, and my editor laughed at me. I stayed up three nights reviewing forty-seven clips to prove I was not making it up. Since then I have known that a contrarian opinion is only worth something if you can pay for it with specifics. La Masia does not produce players. La Masia produces a way of thinking. And no column measures that.
But I also know the cost of eyes without numbers. In 2026, at the European Championship, I sat in a press room after Italy beat Belgium. An older male journalist announced loudly that I should ask about a player’s haircut, not about pressing. I did not stay quiet. I read out the numbers — Italy won the duel percentage, with eleven successful tackles coming from midfield — and asked why Belgium could not escape. A piece I wrote afterwards drew one hundred and twenty thousand reads in twenty-four hours.
Without those numbers I would have been a woman arguing with an older man. The data gave me a voice. So I cannot stand here and say data is meaningless. The problem is elsewhere: data is being used to replace the voice instead of granting it.
And here I have to argue against myself.
The strongest counter-case is this: N/A may be the most honest thing football has ever produced. For a century the sport ran on a coach’s gut and an owner’s mood. Decisions about people were made from a match somebody happened to catch on television. Deals were closed on the word of an agent with an obvious conflict of interest. Now, for the first time, we have a document that dares to say: I do not know.
That is progress. It may be the biggest progress the profession has made.
And perhaps I am the problem. I am the one demanding a full table, because a full table is easier to write about. I am the one who goes to the analytics department and asks for a conclusion, and who cannot produce a high-traffic article out of N/A.
I have been guilty of the same sin. I once built a piece on a data table from a match I had never re-watched. It was wrong. I rarely tell that story.
There is also this: I write for the Chinese market, and I know what it rewards. Shock. Decisiveness. The “I told you so” arc. A piece that says “I am not certain” will not be shared. A piece that says “I am certain” will be read hundreds of thousands of times. I am inside the same system I am criticising — a smaller-scale manufacturer of false certainty, with better prose.
In 2026 I wrote that Russia would reach the World Cup semi-finals on fitness, cold weather and being underestimated. Forums called me delusional for a week. Then Russia beat Spain on penalties, and my old piece resurfaced. I learned one rule from it: never say something vague like “this team will surprise people”. Say something specific enough to be wrong. I wrote that their keeper would save at least two penalties. That detail is why people came back.
The problem is that if you say something falsifiable, you must survive being wrong. This industry cannot. It rewards people who are wrong and never mention it. It punishes people who say they do not yet know.
So when I defend N/A, I am defending something I violate weekly.
The line I want to keep is small and difficult. There is a distance between “I do not know yet” and “I will never know, and I have stopped trying”. A report reading N/A because the sample is four matches is honest. A report reading N/A because nobody bothered to build a model for losing your striker in a final is laziness. Both appear on the page as the same three characters. That is why N/A is dangerous: it cannot distinguish virtue from neglect.
A mature analytics system must do two things it currently does not. It must state what it does not know. And it must state what it is trying to find out next.
Based on my experience following Asian football, my two markets sit on opposite sides of that line. China once had money and bought certainty. Now the money is gone and the certainty went with the analytics departments, leaving people who still know the job but have no table to write into. Vietnam never had the money. That means a good analyst there still works with eyes more than software — and I suspect, though I may be wrong, that this scarcity is producing a generation of football people who can actually see.
The final on 5 January 2026 was not won by a model. It was won by a team that kept its head after losing its main striker in an away final. No data vendor charges for that moment.
So what am I betting on?
In the next twenty-four months, at least one Southeast Asian club will publicly publish a “white report” — a document listing what the club does not know — and use it for recruitment and communications. Every club says it is well prepared. The first to say it does not know will capture attention that full reports are losing.
By 2027, at least one V.League club will publish open event data instead of renting it from a monopoly vendor. That is not a technology prediction. It is economics: squeezed budgets reveal that data is property to own, not a fee to pay every year.
And a prediction about me. Within two years I will publish an analysis whose conclusion is an open question, knowing it will get fewer reads. If I do not, call me a hypocrite and quote this article back at me.
I do not think analytics departments should close. I think they should learn to say the hardest sentence in any language: I do not know yet, and here is what I will do next.
Some revolutions do not fire guns. They just quietly pass the ball. One of those passes may be a blank cell filled in with the reason it was blank.



Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
Lack of Information in Vietnamese Football Analysis: Lessons from Empty Analyses2026-09-10
Anatomy of a Football Analysis: When Data Must Answer for Itself2026-10-04
Juan Cuadrado Leaves European Football: The Right Corridor, Spatial Pressure, and 16 Years That Cannot Be Recreated2026-09-12
The Wrong Label and 15 Million Records: When a Football Pipeline Swallows a Data Incident2026-09-21
Pipeline Alert: A Source Tagged "Football" That Contains No Sports Content2026-09-19
Bài đề xuất
Ulrich Picks Germany, PSSI Turns to Arsenal's 19-Year-Old: A Bet on Passports, Not on Form2026-10-20
Six Goals, Two Dembele Moments and Three Missing Numbers: Re-reading PSG's Opener With Data2026-09-11
Gilberto Mora: One Perfect Moment and an Empty File2026-09-27
Calcutta Football League Derby: East Bengal Rotates Squad for ACL2, Mohun Bagan Super Giant Rallies to Avenge 4-1 Durand Cup Loss2026-09-08
Italy vs France: Bastoni Repays His World Cup Debt While Mancini Searches for a Tactical Identity2026-10-02
Ounahi's Return to Panathinaikos: A 25 Million Euro Test for the Ambition to Break Olympiacos' Era2026-09-03
Bài đề xuất
Oman exit the Gulf Cup after a 1-0 defeat: the midfield dispute and the leadership vacuum2026-10-05
V.League Transfer Window: Release Clauses and Wage Bills Are the Real Story2026-10-03
Lack of Information in Vietnamese Football Analysis: Lessons from Empty Analyses2026-09-10
Nine Debutants and a Self-Contradicting List: Reading Italy's Squad Call-Up Again2026-09-20
Bayern and the JJ Gabriel Deal: Money, Passports and the Limits of the Age-15 Market2026-10-06
The Empty Return: Women's Football and the Cost of Going Unmeasured2026-09-14
Bài đề xuất
The Foretold Death of the Traditional Winger: What a Decade of Football Has Lost2026-10-01
Mourinho and the lesson of missed shots: when goals are not everything2026-09-11
Indonesia vs Thailand Final: Garuda ID, a Three-Day Ticket Window, and the Suspicious FIFA Name2026-10-04
When a Legendary Star Is Defaced: Crisis Management Lessons from the Walk of Fame2026-09-04
Neymar Injury at Santos: Deep Analysis of Relegation Risks and Tactical Dependency2026-09-06
Ounahi's Return to Panathinaikos: A 25 Million Euro Test for the Ambition to Break Olympiacos' Era2026-09-03
